Why the Spending Review should herald a new approach to our public finances

Written by Rob Whiteman on 3 September 2015 in Opinion
Opinion

The forthcoming Spending Review must focus on outcomes and delivery, and also be the springboard for an honest debate about the very nature of our public sector, argues CIPFA's Rob Whiteman

George Osborne’s forthcoming Spending Review will no doubt generate many column inches and soundbites as politicians from all parties try and convince us of its merits or otherwise. Such vigorous debate is, of course, to be welcomed but without a change of approach it won’t shine a light on the most pressing underlying issue – namely what kind of public sector can we realistically afford over the next 10 to 20 years?
 
This is at the heart of many of the problems in our national discourse. In continuing to duck the challenges of a more informed conversation and relying on an over simplified narrative of spending and cuts, government and all parties are collectively turning a blind eye to some uncomfortable problems. 
 
So what is the alternative? Rather than only looking for piecemeal reductions and slicing away at different areas of spending that aren’t protected, the government should instead focus on the whole of public services and what is delivered.


Related content:
Emran Mian: George Osborne's Spending Review will only succeed with proper insight and planning
Peter Riddell: George Osborne has eased the spending squeeze – but there’s more to come in the autumn​
Josie Cluer: The Spending Review challenge will mean a radical rethink of public services
Facing the spending review? Five things to think about…​


We think the Spending Review should focus on three specific areas: 

First, the government needs to consider services and not just money. It really shouldn’t need saying, but outcomes do matter. So the Spending Review must take into account analysis beyond the usual comfort zone, and consider the effectiveness of the whole system where the interconnectedness of public services has never been more important. Cutting housing provision to the bone may affect people’s health or children’s educational achievements more than discrete spending decisions made in those areas. Should we be surprised A&E departments are much busier when social care is cut by more than a third?
 
Secondly, the Spending Review should encourage departments to break down barriers across Whitehall and improve the integration and efficiency of services and systems. There should be greater integration across the whole of the criminal justice system, for instance, including intelligence-gathering at home and overseas, instead of focusing on individual departmental priorities and budgets.
 
Similarly, ring-fencing of budgets in health, defence and overseas aid and maintaining the triple lock on pensions, serves only to exacerbate the problems of unprotected departments and stands in the way of evidence-based policymaking. Saving money can improve quality, but it is intellectually weak to only apply this culture to a few areas, while promising protection to the rest. This fuels the culture that more money is needed to improve things and solve all of our problems. Protection is the surest way to stifle innovation and defer indefinitely the transformation which some of these sacred cows must necessarily undergo if we are to achieve better societal outcomes and coherent public finances.
 
Thirdly, the government should focus on medium-term financial planning, early intervention and prevention instead of limiting financial targets to electoral cycles. The Treasury has a depressing recent track record after it targeted public health budgets in June because of an underspend in 2013-2014 caused by transition, prompting much well-founded criticism from the local government and health sectors. Not only has this highlighted the government’s reluctance to let go of the reins and empower budget holders to plan across years, but it also calls into question their commitment to prevention in the health system rather than fire-fighting acute pressures.
 
In summary, the Spending Review should be a springboard towards an honest and informed debate. It should be focused on service outcomes and delivery and not simply spending. It should break down the silos of Whitehall to promote a whole-system approach, empowering departments to genuinely transform, invest for the future and plan for the medium term.
 
If the government can pull off this ambitious task and sell it to parliament and the country, perhaps the UK will get the Spending Review it needs.
 

 

About the author

Rob Whiteman is CEO of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy

Share this page

Further reading in our policy hubs

Add new comment

Comments

Garin Bodmin (not verified)

Submitted on 30 September, 2015 - 21:35
The Tories don't want a public sector, so the more that leave, the merrier for them. Public sector bad, private sector good is their mantra. Downsizing by stealth, but the lunacy of the loony right, is they expect the same outputs with half the staff!!!! It won't change, the English will continue to vote Tory in their droves, even when public services begin to fail, as they already are beginning to show cracks.

Contact the author

The contact details for the Civil Service World editorial team are available on our About Us page.

Related Articles

Geospatial Commission created to open up government-held mapping data

23 November 2017

Government claims better use of location data produced by public bodies could grow the economy...

Hammond's Budget pours more fuel on the house price fire

23 November 2017

The plans announced in the 2017 Budget may help to tackle Britain’s housing shortage in the long...

Garry Graham: Budget pay betrayal for civil servants

22 November 2017

Philip Hammond’s decision to not set out plans to lift the pay cap for civil servants has placed...

Related Sponsored Articles

A radical re-think for public sector transformation
2 November 2015

With the ‘low-hanging fruit’ exhausted, the public sector must approach new government saving...

Successful partnerships: working effectively with central government
26 August 2014

TCS is keen to contribute to the topic of successful partnerships between the public and private...