Somme centenary: Let's not forget the outstanding civil servants who braved the trenches

Written by Christopher Jary on 1 July 2016 in Feature
Feature

Christopher Jary remembers the civil servants who volunteered to fight for their country in the Great War as recalled in Jill Knight’s book, The Civil Service Rifles in the Great War: ‘All Bloody Gentlemen’

Memorial poppies placed in front of the Thiepval Museum. Image: Chris Radburn/PA

The civil service is not strong on remembering its own history. How many of us, serving or retired, know about our regiment’s part in the Great War? Until I read this book, despite 35 years in the service and an active interest in military history, I thought that the Rifles were created in 1914 to encourage civil servants to enlist and that they formed a single battalion of the London Regiment. I was wrong on both counts – as this excellent book, written in 2004 by Jill Knight of the Foreign Office and the Department of Trade and Industry, has shown me.

The Civil Service Rifles were not creatures of Kitchener’s or Derby’s recruitment appeals. They made up a London volunteer unit that traced its origins to the mid-19th century – and beyond – and that drew its part-time recruits from young men in the public service. The Rifles sent 136 soldiers to fight the Boers in South Africa and some Boer War veterans also fought in the First World War.


Experts back Butler in call to appoint historical advisers
DCMS permanent secretary Sue Owen: "Focus on people and get the leadership right"
Being a generalist is great, but institutional memory gets lost: Ben Goldacre on the civil service


Such was the flood of new recruits in August 1914 that the regiment formed a second battalion. A third battalion followed but did not go overseas: its role was to supply trained men for the two fighting battalions. The 1st Battalion went to France in March 1915 and fought at Festubert, Loos, Vimy Ridge, the Somme, Messines, Cambrai, the retreat of March and April 1918, and the advances from August 1918 until the Armistice. To their chagrin, the 2nd Battalion stayed in England until April 1916. They even wrote a song about it: 

We’ve been to Dorking, Watford, Ware,
Old Saffron Walden, we’ve been there,
One of these days, so please the Lord,
If we’re in luck, we’ll go abroad

But, after an uneventful spell in Ireland following the Easter Rising, they caught up with their foreign travel. Three months on Vimy Ridge between June and October 1916 were followed by six months fighting Bulgarians in Salonika and a year fighting Turks in Egypt and Palestine, capturing and defending Jerusalem, before returning to France to take part in the final advances of 1918. Jill Knight’s very human account tells the whole story, often most touchingly and lucidly in the riflemen’s own well-chosen words.

"Given the disparity between the popular stereotypes of civil servants and soldiers, would you expect a regiment of faceless bureaucrats to be outstanding? Well, they were."

Now seems a good moment to consider their story because a century ago, two battalions of Civil Service Riflemen were serving in the trenches. 

Today we will remember the Somme Offensive, which began on 1 July and ground to its murderous, muddy halt on 18 November 1916. A million men were killed or wounded in one of the bloodiest battles in the history of war. A turning point in modern history, this was the beginning of industrialised, total war. Battle was no longer a clash between regular armies reinforced by volunteers; it was now a grinding campaign of attrition between the industrial muscle and manpower of two groups of nations. After the Somme, Great Britain changed socially, politically and spiritually. A proud, confident nation now bore a painful scar.

Given the disparity between the popular stereotypes of civil servants and soldiers, would you expect a regiment of faceless bureaucrats to be outstanding? Well, they were. 

The Rifles won 27 battle honours, 329 gallantry awards and 116 mentions in Despatches. So good were they that 967 of their men – 14% of those sent overseas – were commissioned. Educated men – hence the book’s title – they excelled as soldiers. From the outset, as the book describes “Many… were work colleagues and friends; a lot had attended the same schools; and a number were related, either directly or by marriage. These relationships crossed all ranks and there was no deep divide between officers and men.” 

Later, a regular commanding officer tried unsuccessfully to introduce pre-war regular Army relationships into the 2nd Battalion. “There was general relief when… he was succeeded by an informal, cheery young regular captain on promotion… Overnight friendly officer-man relations were restored, without detriment to military discipline.” One veteran remembered: “He realised very early the type of men of whom the battalion was composed, and was content to lead and guide rather than to drive. Destructive criticism had no place in his armoury.”

Much of their leadership was home-grown. The last commanding officer of the 2nd Battalion was Lieutenant-Colonel Augustus Benké, a Home Office official who joined the Rifles in 1910. After service in France with the 1st Battalion, he fought with the 2nd in Salonika and Egypt and rose to command the battalion in the last months of the war. After the war he was appointed OBE for his service as a prison governor, adding the decoration to the DSO, MC and mention in Despatches he had received during a dazzling career as an infantry officer. That leadership permeated all ranks. 

Take sergeant-major FC Robertson of the 1st Battalion (once Board of Education), who won a DCM, or Corporal Francis Martin, previously a local government official in Reading and later commissioned into another regiment. These were typical of the men of all ranks who together created the regiment’s unique culture.

Siegfried Sassoon saw the reinforcements arriving before the Somme as “drafts of volunteers” and afterwards as “droves of victims”. Impressively, despite heavy casualties and huge numbers of reinforcements – most of whom were not civil servants – the Rifles maintained their own character and discipline to the end. Reinforcements were absorbed who in turn subtly absorbed the brave and democratic spirit created by the early volunteers. 

On a terrace on the Thames embankment side of Somerset House, stands a column. Designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens, it commemorates 1,240 Civil Service Riflemen killed in the First World War. Next time we’re near the Strand, let’s pop along and spend a minute – or perhaps two – thinking about these predecessors of ours who confronted the horrors of world war and did their duty.

And, while we’re there, we can also remember Jill Knight who, having told their remarkable story, died much too young.

Author Display Name
Christopher Jary
About the author

Christopher Jary spent half his 35-year career in the Employment Department/MSC and the other half teaching at the Civil Service College.  He wrote Working with Ministers and Joining the Civil Service and co-wrote (with Paul Grant) Understanding British Government.  He now writes – mainly military history books – and lives in Dorset.

Jill Knight worked in the FCO and then in the Department of Trade and Industry.  She was the driving force behind a new war memorial plaque which was unveiled in (what is now) BIS headquarters on Armistice Day 2002 as a replacement for a Roll of Honour of staff of the Board of Trade who fell in the First World War. Civil Service Rifles was then published in late 2004 before Jill very sadly died of cancer at the age of 55 in April 2005

The Civil Service Rifles in the Great War: ‘All Bloody Gentlemen’ (2004) by Jill Knight is published by Pen & Sword Books

Share this page
Editor's Pick
Promote as primary content
Not Promoted

Share this page

Further reading in our policy hubs

CONTRIBUTIONS FROM READERS

Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Comments

Mike Newbury (not verified)

Submitted on 1 July, 2016 - 16:15
Thank you so much for this article. You may be interested in the work of a staff group in the NAO that touches on the Civil Service Rifles. Many of our predecessors served in this Regiment's two battalions that saw overseas service. We have casualties recorded on our Roll of Honour in most theatres of the War and many of our fatalities served in the Civil Service Rifles. Our twitterfeed (@PoWCSR100) details the day to day activities of the Regiment and you will find Communities for the Civil Service Rifles on the Imperial War Museums Lives of the First World War Digital Memorial. Many civil servants were involved in the action at Gommecourt on 1 July 1916 whilst serving with the 56th (London) Division in London Battalions such as the London Rifle Brigade and London Scottish. Because of the Civil Service's great contribution to the pre-War Territorials many had been promoted to be officers by mid-1916. And, of course, officers suffered terrible casualty rates too. It was truly a terrible day.

Jeremy Lynn (not verified)

Submitted on 2 July, 2016 - 12:36
Interesting reading! Forgive me for this trivia, but I ate my porridge this morning off a silver spoon hallmarked London 1889/90. It bears the crest of the Civil Service Rifle Volunteers, and a crown with three feathers. Unless the crest was added later, it would show the Volunteers to have been in existence 25 years before the war, and dining off some fine flatware!

michael barton (not verified)

Submitted on 4 July, 2016 - 16:18
my father private Percy Thomas served in Palestine 1916-18 having had training at Hazley Down camp. i have his write up on his experiences of trying to join up, being a craftsman and not a CS. Gladly send it is anyone interested - michael.barton@talktalk.net

Peter Dickens (not verified)

Submitted on 10 August, 2016 - 17:39
There were in fact a number of Volunteer Rifle Regiments formed during the reign of Queen Victoria. One of them based at Davies Street called the Queen Victoria Rifles. The QVR went on to become part of 4 RGJ and now a Rifle Company of 7 Rifles. The London Scottish Regiement was formed along with the London Rish Rifles, both still exist as part of the London Regiment.

Contact the author

The contact details for the Civil Service World editorial team are available on our About Us page.

Related Articles

Related Sponsored Articles

A radical re-think for public sector transformation
2 November 2015

With the ‘low-hanging fruit’ exhausted, the public sector must approach new government saving...

Successful partnerships: working effectively with central government
26 August 2014

TCS is keen to contribute to the topic of successful partnerships between the public and private...