Leaked report casts doubt on Troubled Families programme

Written by Josh May on 9 August 2016 in News

Official evaluation seen by Newsnight suggests much-heralded programme has had a limited impact on employment, criminality and truancy

The government has been accused of sitting on a report which found its flagship initiative to help troubled families had no “measurable impact” on the targets of the programme. 

The scheme, hailed by David Cameron as a “real success” last July, was launched after the London riots in 2011. Troubled families are defined as those with long-standing problems, inlcuding long-term unemployment, exclusion from school, and exposure to domestic violence.

But BBC Newsnight has seen an official evaluation which casts doubt on whether the programme has had any influence on employment, criminality and truancy.

Speaking truth to power: CSW interviews Troubled Families tsar Louise Casey
DCLG announce new scheme to measure success of Troubled Families programme
Troubled Families on track to hit target, Eric Pickles announces

Based on data from 56 local authorities, the analysis by consultancy firm Ecorys said: “The lack of obvious effect from the programme across a range of outcomes indicates that the programme did not have a measurable impact on families within the time-frame over which it was possible to observe its effects.”

Ecorys found there was no “discernible impact” on the proportion of those in ‘troubled families’ claiming out-of-work benefits or the rates of adult offending, “no obvious impact” on employment, “no detectable impact” on child offending, and no clear conclusions on truancy.

An official told Newsnight that publication of the report was being held back because of its findings, an accusation denied by a departmental spokesperson, who said: "There were several strands to the evaluation work commissioned by the last government and there is not yet a final report."

In June last year Mr Cameron described the scheme as a “real government success”.

“Almost all of the 117,000 families which the programme started working with have now been turned around – in terms of either school attendance or getting a job or both,” he said.

The former prime minister added that he wanted it to reach 400,000 more families by the end of the decade.

Families in the programme receive a designated social worker to coordinate how public services can help them with entrenched problems.

Local authorities receive £3,200 for every family identified and a further £800 if they are deemed “turned around”, which requires some improvement on truancy or criminality.  

Author Display Name
Josh May
About the author

Josh May is news editor of PoliticsHome.com, where a version of this story first appeared

Share this page
Editor's Pick
Promote as primary content
Not Promoted

Share this page

Further reading in our policy hubs


Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.


Professor D P Gregg (not verified)

Submitted on 16 September, 2016 - 12:24
I have been researching the TFP and the Family Intervention Projects on which it is based for many years. The first Dundee Family Project was in 1999. Analysis of the several government sponsored evaluation reports, by several academic teams, over this period shows NO sustained impact on any 'success' measures used. Successive governments have known that these expensive projects do not work. What is worse the families targeted are not criminal but have very high levels of physical and mental illness and disabilities. See my book 'Troubled families',Green Man Books. It's on Amazon, etc. This is a national scandal on several levels.

Contact the author

The contact details for the Civil Service World editorial team are available on our About Us page.

Related Articles

Related Sponsored Articles